THE EDUCATIONAL POLICIES OF THE SERBIAN STATE TO THE ALBANIAN MINORITY IN SERBIA

  • Liburn Mustafë Mustafa South East European University, Tetovo
Keywords: Albanian minority in Serbia, education in Albanian language, lack of textbooks in Albanian, equal rights for national minorities, reciprocity

Abstract

The right to be educated in mother tongue is considered among the most important human rights in the contemporary world. Such a right is guaranteed to the all world communities in spite of the state and international rights, regardless of the location, extent, and size of the community. Every state is obliged to respect and make possible the realization of the rights to be educated in their language to every minority within it, because the right to education in mother tongue is now considered a crucial tool for preserving and strengthening the cultural and ethnic identity, and vice versa, the non-implementation of these rights to certain communities implies the state's tendency towards these communities. Also, minorities are predestined that the educations in their language attend similar to their mother country, based on textbooks and curricula of the respective states, as such a right is guaranteed by international norms and conventions. But such a thing, very often faces a strong resistance from the states where these minorities are, because in these textbooks is reflected the history, culture and tradition of the past, which in most cases is a clash between identities and produce numerous value controversies between the parties. This situation is particularly reflected in some Balkan countries where ethnic minorities are not "bridges" between communities but are "quarrelsome" among communities. In such a situation is the Albanian minority in Serbia, who because of the conflicting past between the two nationalities, the Albanian and the Serbs, are victimized by preventing the right to learn their history, culture, tradition and their mother tongue. Thus the Serbian state, because of the past between the two nations and issues still open with the state of Kosovo, denies Albanians in Serbia using textbooks from this country. This form of approach reflects state policies on curricula and textbooks currently being implemented by the Albanian minority. In this paper we will explain the problems faced by the Albanian minority in Serbia in the field of education, respectively the problems of the lack of textbooks in Albanian language. We will present the causes and obstacles of the lack of school textbooks in Albanian language in Presheva Valley schools, strategies developed by various factors to solve this problem, implicated parties, legal rights issues and the possible solution of this problem.

References

Ejupi, A. (2013). Presheva Valley, geospatial complex. ASHAK, Pristina.

Ejupi, A. (2016). Nature of the Presevo Valley, structures, determinants and natural resources. ASHAK, Pristina.

Emini, A. (2016). Presheva in the streams of history (20th century). Focus Print, Skopje.

Haki, S.; Selver, M. & Rexhep, S. (2001). Primary Albanian Education in the Presheva Municipality 1945 – 95. GRFOFLEX, Preshevë.

History of Albanian People IV. (2009). Toena, Tiranë.

Latifi, Skender. (1997). Eastern Kosovo, p.v.b. Preshevë.

Pettifer. J, V. M. (2007). Albanian affair, Libri, Tiranë.

Qazimi, S., (2010) Presheva survived historical and actual trials, Enis Graf, Preshevë.

Zylfiu, I., (2015). Albanian minority in Serbia: comparative approach, PHD work, University of Tirana. Institute of European Studies, Tirana.

Interview with Director of the High School "Skënderbeu", Mr. Nadër Sadiku.

Interview with Professor History at “Skëndërbeu” High School, Mr. Ilir Zylfiu.

(2002) Law on the Protection and Freedom of the National Minority.

(2006) Constitution of the Republic of Serbia, Article I.

(2011) Census of Population, Households and Dwellings in the Republic of Serbia, Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia, Belgrade, 2012.

(2014) Law on National Councils of National Minorities in Serbia.

Agreement reached, valley students with textbooks from Albania http://shenja.tv/arrihet-marreveshja-nxenesit-e-lugines-me-tekste-shkollore-nga-shqiperia/; 10. 06. 2019.

Albanian National Council in Serbia, Report on the Situation of the Albanian Community in Serbia, september, 2015.

Albanian National Council in Serbia, Strategic Plan of the ANC, 2012-2016.

Albanian youth in Serbia suffer the textbook disagreement: http://www.balkaninsight.com/al/article/të-rinjtë-shqiptarë-në-serbi-vuajnë-mosmarrëveshjen-e-teksteve-shkollore-06-09-2016, 23. 06.2019.

Albanians in Serbia protest textbooks from Kosovo, 2016, http://www.balkaninsight.com/al/article/shqiptarët-e-serbisë-protestojnë-për-tekstet-shkollore-nga-kosova-02-18-2016, 02.07.2018.

Albanians in Serbia, Swedish Helsinki Committee for Human Rights, 2003.

Ambassador Davenport speaks of the lack of textbooks in the Valley and Kosovo diplomas:http://www.titulli.com/ambasadori-davenport-flet-për-mungesën-e-teksteve-mësimore-në-luginë-dhe-diplomat-e-kosovës, 21.06.2019.

ANC: "The Beginning of the End of Discrimination with the Lack of School Books": http://www.rtvaldi.com/page.php?id_neës=21567; 30.06.2019.

Belgzim Kamberi: Serbia vs. Valley Albanians has changed the method but not the content,http://www.shqiperianatyrale.com/index.php?option=com_content&vieë=article&id=1293:kamberi-serbia-ndaj-shqiptareve-te-lugines-ka-ndryshuar-metoden-por-jo-permbajtjen&catid=1:latest-neës&Itemid=18, 29.06.2019.

Contesting Memorandum for Translation of Books / Document; http://siagora.net/files/2016/09/Memorandumi-Librave.pdf; 02.07.2019.

Coordination Body for Presevo, Bujanovac and Medvedja; http://www.kt.gov.rs/lt/articles/rreth-nesh/historiku-dhe-misioni/; 30.06.2019.

Former Ambassador, Qaushi signed the "pro" removal of Albanian symbols from the Abetare: http://www.nacionalalbania.al/2013/12/ish-ambasadori-caushi-firmosi-pro-heqjes-se-simboleve-shqiptare-nga-abetarja/; 18.06.2019.

Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities and Explanatory Report, Article 6, paragraphs 1 and 2.

Gap Institute, Governance Report in four Northern Municipalities, September 2015, http://www.institutigap.org/documents/3068_Veriu%202.pdf , 20. 06.2018.

https://zeri.info/zerat/103224/nje-tekst-per-skandalin-e-teksteve/; 01.07.2019.

Interview, Riza Halimi, continues discrimination of the Albanian school in the Valley: http://telegrafi.com/halimi-po-vazhdon-diskriminimi-i-shkolles-shqipe-ne-lugine/, 30.06.2019.

Kosovo and Serbia agree to Exchange textbooks, http://www.balkaninsight.com/al/article/kosova-dhe-serbia-pranojnë-të-shkëmbejnë-libra-shkollorë-09-10-2015; 02.07.2019.

Kosovo and Serbia agree to exchange textbooks: http://www.balkaninsight.com/al/article/kosova-dhe-serbia-pranojnë-të-shkëmbejnë-libra-shkollorë-09-10-2015

Kosovo-Serbia agreement on school textbooks is cut off, https://balkaninsight.com/2015/09/25/prishet-marrëveshja-kosovë-serbi-për-tekstet-shkollore-09-25-2015/?lan; 19. 06.2019.

Kosovo-Serbia Dialogue: Challenge and Pathway, IDK, 2018,http://kdi-kosova.org/ëp-content/uploads/2018/03/18-Sfidat-FINAL-ALB-06.pdf, 20.06.2019.

Latif Mustafa, A Text for the Scandal of Texts,

Nagavaci: Albanians in the Valley live in extraordinary conditions, they are denied of the right for basic quality education: https://telegrafi.com/nagavci-shqiptaret-ne-lugine-jetojne-ne-kushte-te-jashtezakonshme-u-mohohet-edhe-e-drejta-per-arsim-bazik-cilesor/; 25. 06.2019.

Presevo, Albanian schools at risk; http://shenja.mk/index.php/lajme/rajoni/16802-presheve-shkollat-shqipe-ne-rrezik.html; 25.06.2019.

Report of the National Council of the Albanian National Minorities on the implementation of the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages; http://www.knsh.org/Portals/0/Plani/Raporti%20mbi%20zbatimin%20e%20Konventes%20evropiane%20mbi%20gjuhet%20rajonale%20ose%20minoritare,%2003.12.2013%20II.pdf, 25.06.2019.

Serbia to the Albanians of the Valley has changed the method, but not the content; http://www.shqiperianatyrale.com/index.php?option=com_content&vieë=article&id=12793:kamberi-serbia-ndaj-shqiptareve-te-lugines-ka-ndryshuar-metoden-por-jo-permbajtjen&catid=1:latest-neës&Itemid=18; 25.06.2019.

VV: 107 years from the Congress of Manastir - Valley without texts in Albanian https://www.botasot.info/lajme/482116/vv-107-vjet-nga-kongresi-i-manastirit-lugina-pa-tekste-ne-shqip/; 22.06.2019.

With a protest is marked the first class in all of the Valley’s schools: http://www.kosovalindore.com/me-proteste-shenohet-ora-e-pare-mesimore-ne-te-gjitha-shkollat-e-lugines/, 21.06.2019.

Published
2019-07-26
How to Cite
Mustafë Mustafa, L. (2019). THE EDUCATIONAL POLICIES OF THE SERBIAN STATE TO THE ALBANIAN MINORITY IN SERBIA. Knowledge International Journal, 32(1), 129 - 136. Retrieved from https://ikm.mk/ojs/index.php/KIJ/article/view/1415